RoboBoom
Marwa ElDiwiny· September 17, 2024· 53:10

Uncovering the 1X NEO Humanoid Tendon-Driven Arm: Scott Walter's In-Depth Investigation

Scott Walter, a robotics investigator, explains 1X’s NEO tendon-driven arm and hand to Marwa ElDiwiny on her channel, comparing the design with Tesla Optimus and other humanoids.

In this talk

  1. 1:35

    Why NEO is so light

    Walter estimates NEO at about 30 kilograms, compared with roughly 55 to 56 kilograms for Tesla Optimus. He attributes the gap partly to a battery about one-fifth the size and to lighter actuators. 1X’s low-ratio, backdrivable design also aims to reduce gearing and improve safety around people.

  2. 10:02

    How the tendon-driven arm moves

    Walter uses a 3D model to explain how actuators near the shoulder can drive joints farther down the arm through tendons and pulleys. Paired actuators moving together produce one motion, while opposing movement produces another, such as wrist pitch versus yaw. This arrangement moves actuator mass closer to the torso and helps reduce the load on the arm.

  3. 24:45

    Design tradeoffs and open questions

    Walter identifies tendon wear, stretching, and calibration as potential challenges. He says the patent discusses durable synthetic fiber, likely Vectran, and describes ways to address cogging and changing tendon lengths. He also notes that routing tendons through the wrist and hand makes control and modeling more complex, though machine learning may help compensate.

  4. 34:12

    How 1X compares with other humanoids

    Walter contrasts 1X’s tendon approach with high-ratio actuators common among North American robot makers and lower-ratio designs used by some Chinese companies. He describes Tesla’s wrist as using stiff linkages and says moving its hand actuators into the forearm could be difficult because space is limited. He sees 1X’s compact, human-shaped hand as a notable integration achievement, while acknowledging that the internal design is not fully visible.

  5. 38:28

    Iteration, cost, and the legs

    Walter expects 1X, Tesla, and Figure to keep revising their robots, balancing new hardware designs against the need to deploy robots and gather data. He says lighter construction can reduce material use, but manufacturing and assembly drive much of the cost; 1X may also simplify production by reusing actuator types. He expects the leg to use principles similar to the arm and cites a target of walking around 2.5 miles per hour and running around 7.

Briefs summarise talks and interviews; timestamps open the video at that moment. Claims in a talk are the speaker's own.

More talks